Thread: 10 Best Oline & Dline Prospects for the Bears

i'd take ANYTHING from bleacher report with a 50lb grain of salt,soul.. not real reporters or have any special knowledge of sports or bears, just mesage board posters, putting stuff in article form...mostly high school kids


About Bob



"Better to write for yourself and have no public, than to write for the public and have no self. "
- Cyril Connolly
Read more from me on Chicago Bears Huddle: http://chicagonow.com/chicagobearshuddle
Follow me on Twitter @bobwarja

I am currently a community leader and a featured columnist covering the Cubs and Bears for Bleacher Report. Furthermore, I've recently discovered verbs, which has really brightened up my articles!

On a personal note, I have three kids, one of each. If you want to know more about me, Bleacher Report colleague Sam Wenk was kind enough to do a brief profile on me for B/R:

That really doesn't make a difference to me if he's just an ordinary "Joe" like all of us. What piqued my interest is just how close he is to playing the Bears draft hand about the same way as we post about it here. Maybe he follows our threads, LOL.

With the exception of suggesting Taylor as a possible 2nd round Bears pick I'd agree with just about everything else. To me Carimi, Liuget and Pouncey should be the guys at the top of our board. I'd also agree with taking Liuget over Carimi if both were still there (unlikely) and Pouncey over Sherrod in neither Carimi or Liuget were.

Just another guy who's analyzing the draft based on the Bears real needs and who might fall, not just the top rated player available.

Originally Posted by soulman

That really doesn't make a difference to me if he's just an ordinary "Joe" like all of us. What piqued my interest is just how close he is to playing the Bears draft hand about the same way as we post about it here. Maybe he follows our threads, LOL.

With the exception of suggesting Taylor as a possible 2nd round Bears pick I'd agree with just about everything else. To me Carimi, Liuget and Pouncey should be the guys at the top of our board. I'd also agree with taking Liuget over Carimi if both were still there (unlikely) and Pouncey over Sherrod in neither Carimi or Liuget were.

Just another guy who's analyzing the draft based on the Bears real needs and who might fall, not just the top rated player available.

Can someone post the list, I cannot get on bleacher report at work.

Originally Posted by WindyCity

Can someone post the list, I cannot get on bleacher report at work.

I summarized his thoughts in the thread starter Windy. It's not really posted as a list on the website. It's a series of player photos along with his take on each.

Here's another way of looking at it.

Oline: Smith and Solder will be gone before the Bears picks and he's take Carimi over either Castonzo or Sherrod. He's even consider trading up a few notches for Carimi which is in line with one of your ideas. He'd take Pouncey over Sherrod if the top 4 OT's and Liuget are all gone.

Dline: He'd take Liuget over anyone, even Carimi if both were still on the board at #29. His reason for it is because while Liuget is a sure thing at 3t DT Carimi may not be a great LT in the NFL. Fairley and Dareus are gone before we even get a whiff of them. He has Phil Taylor as a possible second round Bears pick.

So here's his list of the top ten.

OT's = Smith, Solder, Carimi, Costanzo, Sherrod

OG's = Pouncey

DT's = Dareus, Fairley, Liuget, Taylor

Originally Posted by soulman

I summarized his thoughts in the thread starter Windy. It's not really posted as a list on the website. It's a series of player photos along with his take on each.

Here's another way of looking at it.

Oline: Smith and Solder will be gone before the Bears picks and he's take Carimi over either Castonzo or Sherrod. He's even consider trading up a few notches for Carimi which is in line with one of your ideas. He'd take Pouncey over Sherrod if the top 4 OT's and Liuget are all gone.

Dline: He'd take Liuget over anyone, even Carimi if both were still on the board at #29. His reason for it is because while Liuget is a sure thing at 3t DT Carimi may not be a great LT in the NFL. Fairley and Dareus are gone before we even get a whiff of them. He has Phil Taylor as a possible second round Bears pick.

So here's his list of the top ten.

OT's = Smith, Solder, Carimi, Costanzo, Sherrod

OG's = Pouncey

DT's = Dareus, Fairley, Liuget, Taylor

Thanks, nothing all that earth shattering.

It will be interesting to see how the OL plays out, but he is the only person other than Baldinger who is down on Costanzo.

Originally Posted by WindyCity

Thanks, nothing all that earth shattering.

It will be interesting to see how the OL plays out, but he is the only person other than Baldinger who is down on Costanzo.

Your welcome. No it's not earth shattering at all. He just seems to agree with what many of us have already come to the conclusion of. At least the guy knows the Bears and their needs better than some and I thought that was important.

Mike Mayock: Marcus Gilbert has been steadily been moving up draft boards. He's a 2nd-round pick with starter potential.

Mike Mayock: James Carpenter is a finesse left tackle. A 2nd-round pick with starter potential.

Mike Mayock: Orlando Franklin is the most physical of the non 1st-round tackles. Rising up charts; not sure if he'll be inside/outside

Mike Mayock: The guy I'm intrigued by is Jah Reid. He's a right tackle only, but he's a starting right tackle 2 years from now.

Originally Posted by WindyCity

Mike Mayock: Marcus Gilbert has been steadily been moving up draft boards. He's a 2nd-round pick with starter potential.

Mike Mayock: James Carpenter is a finesse left tackle. A 2nd-round pick with starter potential.

Mike Mayock: Orlando Franklin is the most physical of the non 1st-round tackles. Rising up charts; not sure if he'll be inside/outside

Mike Mayock: The guy I'm intrigued by is Jah Reid. He's a right tackle only, but he's a starting right tackle 2 years from now.

The Bears looked at Gilbert while they worked Pouncey out. He and Carpenter are most likely two guys the Bears will be looking to land in the second if that first choice goes for Liuget or we take any other DT with our first pick either at #29 or in a trade down. Sizewise I gotta think that Gilbert is more a Tice kind of lineman than Carpenter and Florida generally runs a more pass oriented offense so it's possible that Gilbert is the more advanced pass blocker of the two.

I've about half way given up hope that we'll ever get a shot at Carimi at #29 and I really don't see JA trading up if he thinks he can get either Pouncey or Liuget instead. I also don't think they'll take a chance on Sherrod or Solder. Too many question marks there. So to me it looks like it's very likely we'll take an OT with our second pick and it's just possible that a few of those guys represent as good or better value than anyone in the latter part of round one.

Something makes me think that the Bears are looking at Marcus Gilbert as a possible high pick.

He apparently has a phenomenol pro day and Mayock is pojecting him as a late 1st round pick, which could be interesting.

What do we of the Bears drafting Gilbert?