So if 'only' 3-4 good legs..guess we shall see if zero or only 1-2 punters get drafted, bears will still ahve one of those legs and not wasted a pick for it..guess that i what makes Drafting not an exact science,, or Posting on a mesage board and not making $500,000k or more as a top scout or a player personal guy... and as toub is one of the BEST, if not best ST guy out there, prtty sure he does have a handle on the punting situation for bears, and if we go udfa or even stick with this awful , horrible mdgee guy... don't you think the top ranked ST unit and coach, has input and makes sure the kicker/punters/returners/ coverage units up to snuff?? or are you saying toub doesn't know special teams and he's cluless for signing mcgee?? .. can't imagine the bears gave mcgee a 2 year deal without talking it over with the ST coach, and getting his approval and him wanting him, do you?
Last edited by dabears54; 04-30-2011 at 01:12 PM.
only 10 punters have even been drafted the last 5 years and even on those drafted results mixed and i'd say been more found and successful UDFA's the last 5 years over the drafed one's FWIW:
http://www.nfl.com/draft/history/ful...&type=position
2010 - SPECIALISTSRDSEL #PLAYERPOSITIONSCHOOLTEAM5
150Zoltan Mesko P Michigan New England Patriots
172Brent Bowden P Virginia Tech Tampa Bay Buccaneers
7221Matt Dodge P East Carolina New York Giants
2009 - SPECIALISTSRDSEL #PLAYERPOSITIONSCHOOLTEAM51
142 Kevin Huber PCincinnati Cincinnati Bengals
5164Thomas Morstead P Southern Methodist New Orleans Saints
7 222 Pat McAfee PWest Virginia Indianapolis Colts
2008 - SPECIALISTSRDSEL #PLAYERPOSITIONSCHOOLTEAM
6168Durant Brooks PGeorgia Tech Green Bay Packers
2007 - SPECIALISTSRDSEL #PLAYERPOSITIONSCHOOLTEAM
4 101Adam Podlesh P Maryland Jacksonville Jaguars
4 112Daniel Sepulveda P BaylorPittsburgh Steelers
7 225 Brandon Fields P Michigan State Miami Dolphins
2006 - SPECIALISTSRDSEL #PLAYERPOSITIONSCHOOLTEAM
4 6203 Sam Koch P NebraskaBaltimore Ravens
7239Ryan Plackemeier P Wake ForestSeattle Seahawks
Last edited by dabears54; 04-30-2011 at 01:05 PM.
We're talking about getting the BEST Punter in the draft versus the #10-20+ at virtually all other positions. The league is pretty muc split right in half on punters drafted Vs UDFA, but like I said, best Punter, which is very much a position of need versus 10-20 everywhere else? No-brainer to me. Of course it's all a moot argument since we will draft a crappy 3rd string QB like Yates.