Lovie Backs Martz's Game Plan and Hanie's Play...........

Unlike fired Jack Del Rio, Lovie Smith always backs up his players, coaches
by Mark Potash mpotash@suntimes.com November 29, 2011 8:12PM
nfl’s longest-tenured coaches

The top 11 with regular-season and playoff records:

1. Andy Reid, Eagles (1999) 122-80-1 / 10-9

2. Bill Belichick, Patriots
(2000) 134-53 / 14-5

3. Marvin Lewis, Bengals (2003) 67-71-1 / 0-2

4. LOVIE SMITH, BEARS
(2004) 70-53 / 3-3

4. Tom Coughlin, Giants (2004) 71-52 / 4-3

6. Mike McCarthy, Packers
(2006) 59-32 / 5-2

6. Sean Payton, Saints(2006) 57-34 / 4-2

6. Gary Kubiak, Texans
(2006) 45-46 / 0-0

9. Norv Turner, Chargers (2007) 45-30 / 3-3

9. Mike Tomlin, Steelers
(2007) 51-24 / 5-2

9. Ken Whisenhunt, Cardinals (2007) 36-39 / 4-2


Updated: November 29, 2011 10:05PM


When reporters asked former Jaguars coach Jack Del Rio about his team’s questionable play-calling after a 14-10 loss Nov. 20 to the Browns, he deflected the blame toward his offensive coordinator, Dirk Koetter. ‘‘Our offensive coordinator calls the plays; I can’t speak to his thinking,’’ Del Rio said. ‘‘You’ll have to [talk to] him.’’

When reporters asked Bears coach Lovie Smith about his team’s questionable play-calling after a 25-20 loss Sunday to the Raiders, he defended his coaches and dismissed the queries as second-guessing.
‘‘You mean in hindsight?’’ Smith said when asked if the Bears could’ve taken some of the load off first-time starter Caleb Hanie by running more than 13 times in the first half when Matt Forte and Marion Barber were averaging 5.5 yards per carry. ‘‘I think our game plan was good enough to win the football game. If we eliminate a couple of the turnovers . . . it’s a different ballgame. I like our game plan. We just didn’t make enough plays. We will next [time].’’

And he was even more resolute when asked about the criticism of offensive coordinator Mike Martz for calling a ‘‘throwback screen’’ for Hanie on second-and-one that led to Kamerion Wimbley’s momentum-turning interception.

He wasn’t even asked about the play itself. He was asked if there was at least merit to the argument that you might want to run a safer play in that situation, so at the very least you settle for a field goal for an unlikely halftime lead that would’ve sent the Bears into the locker room feeling pretty good about themselves and the Raiders wondering why they’re losing to Hanie at home.

‘‘No. Maybe from you it is [a legitimate argument],’’ Smith said. ‘‘It didn’t work, so, of course, you’re going to get criticized when something doesn’t work. Next time it will.’’

An unsatisfying answer for those who know the throwback screen was at the very least an illogical or ill-advised call, if not a ‘‘stupid’’ one, as a Halas Hall insider made a point of telling me Monday. But that non-answer is just one reason why Smith is now fourth in the NFL in coaching seniority after Del Rio was fired Tuesday. He’d much rather throw us under the bus than any of his coaches or players.

In his eighth season, Smith is tied with the Giants’ Tom Coughlin behind the Eagles’ Andy Reid (13th season), the Patriots’ Bill Belichick (12th) and the Bengals’ Marvin Lewis (ninth) in seniority. And Coughlin and Reid are on the hot seat after blowout losses this week. So Smith could be in third place all by himself by the end of the season.

Smith’s staying power is respected by many but chagrined by some who think he’s lucky to work for an organization so impervious to outside criticism. There’s no denying his sometimes-annoyingly dispassionate manner works in his favor. While coaches such as Rex Ryan and Jim Schwartz seem destined to implode under the weight of their driven personalities — and white-hot coach-of-the-year-to-be Jim Harbaugh might eventually make that list — Smith just keeps on rollin’ like Old Man River.

The Bears are falling further behind the Packers — a reflection of general manager Ted Thompson’s superiority more than coach Mike McCarthy’s. But if the Bears beat out the Lions for a playoff spot, the difference will be coaching. Schwartz, still rough around the edges, is paying the price for enabling Ndamukong Suh and engendering an aggressive style that crosses the line. The Lions play to ‘‘the echo of the whistle.’’ But they don’t reflexively go after every loose ball like the Bears do under Smith — a flaw that cost them a takeaway against the Bears, by the way.

The aggression Smith promotes doesn’t intimidate, but it puts the Bears in position to take advantage of almost every opportunity — a big reason for their sometimes-uncanny resiliency. That’s why the Bears are one of only five teams to win at least seven games every season since 2005. That’s commendable. But unless Smith finds a way to get the Bears over the top, he’s destined to meet the same fate as Del Rio.

I applaud Lovie for being a "class act" and not throwing his OC and QB under the bus for what turned out to be a game changing and ultimately losing mistake. Lovie has grown into his HC position very nicely and his consistency is commendable but you can only take a trip to the brink so many times before you get questioned about having what it takes to win the big one. Lots of wins but not enough cigars for a guy with his record.

And for the record what he says about Ted Thompson is very true. McCarthy isn't outcoaching Lovie, Thompson is burying Angelo. Give Lovie the Packers helm and let's see what happens.

I don't think it matter whether Lovie gave Martz support or not. I believe his game plan and play calling Sunday, especially that backside screen, have written Martz's epitaph as the Bears OC and I think he knows it which may be why he wasn't more upset after that loss. If the ASU job is open and he's a canidate he can deny it all he want but that where he's headed. Why be restricted from running your "show" in Chicago by a run oriented HC and a GM who won't give in to your every need when you can be the HMIC at ASU? It makes as much sense for him to take that job if offered as it makes sense for us not to offer to renew his deal. To tell the truth I think we dodged a bullet when he declined our earlier offer and I think this team will be better off without him.

There are guys out there who can see the potential of this offense has with Forte and Cutler and would be ready willing and able to take it one step farther on down the line. Personally I think we regress with Martz because we can't play it his way and he can't game plan and call it ours.

Hanie also deserves the opportuntity to play for someone who'll support him 100% and work with him, not against him.