-
Emery Brings Philisophical Change............
Chicago Bears Report
Emery brings philosophical change to Bears
January, 31, 2012 Jan 31
9:44
PM CT
By Michael C. Wright
Recently hired Chicago Bears general manager Phil Emery covered quite a bit of ground Monday during his introductory press conference at Halas Hall, but a couple of things stuck out in regards to his philosophies on talent evaluation and how the team plans to operate in the future.
[+] Enlarge
Denny Medley/US PresswirePhil Emery favors tall wideouts like Jon Baldwin, whom the Chiefs selected in the first round of the 2011 draft.
Emery made it clear the majority of players brought in through the draft and rookie free agency will fit a certain profile -- one that hasn't likely yet been determined. While measureables prove important in talent evaluation, ultimately, the new GM stressed the organization will covet real "men" on the gridiron.
"The measureables are important in terms of high-end productive players, playmakers, dynamic individuals. I kind of call it -- no offense to the ladies in the room -- but the guys that are 'men,'" Emery said. "[The guys you see] that everybody goes, 'Wow, they play like men.' They dominate others. If one may be a little bit faster and they're both playmakers, we might lean toward the one with better measureables because this is a big man's game."
That's not to say that the team plans to kick-start a makeover at certain positions such as receiver, where all but three of the players on the current roster -- Roy Williams, Earl Bennett and Johnny Knox -- stand shorter than 6 feet. But it's clear the majority of players the Bears acquire through the draft and rookie free agency will fit the "big man" profile Emery craves.
"There are smaller players that have success," Emery said. "But overall, history will show you this is a big man's game. Now, where the other aspect comes in [in terms of talent evaluations is] we'll do a re-check as part of our process where we'll really run the numbers hard, looking for those guys later in the draft and college free agency that have the measureables in this league that we may hit on that may be a little underlooked. Maybe they're not quite as productive. We'll dig into the reasons, and those may be players we target."
Emery mentioned plans to keep the current group of scouts in place, but the team's methodology to arriving at player grades will change. Emery spoke intricately about the process he utilizes with team president Ted Phillips and chairman George McCaskey during the interview process. Given the potential for confusion with the regime change, Emery won't implement the club's grading system immediately. But when the team adds to the personnel staff after the draft, look for a method of arriving at grades similar to the system utilized in Atlanta under general manager Thomas Dimitroff.
Approximately an hour after Emery's press conference, he sat down and explained the challenges faced by Dimitroff when he arrived in Atlanta after working with the New England Patriots. During Dimitroff's tenure with the Patriots, the team ran a 3-4 defense, which requires different types of players than the ones needed to excel in the 4-3 defense that Mike Smith brought to the Falcons. Working closely with the coaching staff, Dimitroff came up with a new method for determining the types of players that would fit in Smith's scheme.
Emery said he plans to do something similar in the coming weeks with Bears coach Lovie Smith.
"I don't want to make wholesale changes in terms of how the grades are, you know, what a grade means right now," Emery said. "Because right now we're going to focus on the good scouts that are here, the staff, and getting everybody on the same page in terms of who are the best players in pro free agency -- No. 1 -- and then who are the best players in the draft. Some of those schematic issues won't happen until post-draft. But we will set it up in a way that we will identify players. We'll put labels on players along with our grades to shape how we feel about that player. As we move forward, as our staff is structured, how our scouts scout, how we grade, the grading scale we use, how we use that grading scale, how we balance pro and college, all of that [will be] different."
Although ownership handed Emery complete control over roster decisions, football operations, and Smith's fate as a head coach after 2012, the general manager wants to lean on input from others to make most moves. According to sources, recently-fired general manager Jerry Angelo often strayed from the recommendations of the team's scouts. Emery stressed that he'll make the final decisions on roster moves, but won't do so without sufficient dialogue -- and debate if needed -- with other members of football operations.
"There’s going to be a lot of voices that are involved -- at the appropriate time, and in the appropriate way. It’ll be very professional. It’ll be very thoughtful. It’ll be people working together," Emery said. We may have disagreements. But the professionalism comes in learning how to agree to disagree, and move on to the next player, where we can find a common ground and that player fits our system, our coaches, our community. It will be segmented. Sometimes, you need that outside voice, to open up your mind to other possibilities. And I’m very open to those discussions.
"There will reach a point during this process, where it will be coach Smith and myself developing the plan at the end, and it will be on players that him and I agree upon, in sync, that these are the right players for the Bears. That’s where the heaviest influence will come. At the end of the process, do we have it lined up right? Is coach Smith and I in agreement and in sync with these players, and do we have a plan for that player? Not only to draft him, but post draft; a developmental plan. Knowing that players strengths and weaknesses. Knowing where he needs to go. That’s where coach Smith and I will put in our body of work."
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
-
I'm really having a hard time understanding where some writers get off criticizing Emery for not outlining his plans for the team and how he's going to go about it. To me this article makes it pretty clear so is Michael Wright one of those who listened to what Emery had to say, understood him, and wrote his interpretation of it? Seems so to me.
There are others who appear to have a predetermined dislike for Emery and criticize both what he says and what he doesn't say as if his job is to please them instead of the people who hired him. Maybe everyone needs top step back, take a deep breath and see what the guy can do instead of finding fault with every word that comes out of the man's mouth.
From reading the above I've got a real good idea of where he stands on player personnel. He wants football players more than he wants athletes and that alone will be a major change in how we draft. He plans to involve Lovie in the player selection process but in the final analysis he has the ultimate control of the roster. With the exception of his agreement to retain Lovie for the 2012 season he has complete control of the decisions normally made by NFL GM's. He may not go into minute detail about everything but he doen't owe anyone that and certainly not some sportswriter who thinks he does. Why tip your hand?
One thing I did find interesting was the comment that JA often strayed from his scouts recommendations. Gee, what a surprise. I think we learned about his tendency to do that when he flip flopped and drafting James Starks. No wonder he fired Gabriel and DePaul. Well maybe we can put to rest the idea that Emery must clean house and get rid of all the scouts because they did a lousy job and that's why we drafted so poorly.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
High Fives / Like - 3 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-
I don't want this guy to tip his hat in any sense of the word. I want him to have everyone think it same old-same old around here and surprise the hell out of everyone with a philosophical paradigm shift in thinking. I want the whole league to think this guy is either dumb or crazy-like a fox.
Arguing on the internet is like winning the special olympics, even if you win your still messed up.
Restore the roar!
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-
its easier to take an extreme point of view homer/hater...like/dislike then to be open minded and evaluate a situation and it gets more rating that way so just dont get fooled by these things and make up your own mind
He says some good things about football players wanted and needed. We arent running the olympics this is a fricken football team. Olsen was a good example of being drafted based on a 40 time and not what he did in college and it didnt help us out. Flame away at me with this point but its the damn truth
in the B&B interview the best shit I have heard in a long time is the days of the red shirt player is fucking over. Thank god sanity has returned. Talk about wasted draft pick after wasted draft pick. Emery didnt say he wont be taking any risks he just inteligently said there is a barometer of what is acceptable and where and when in draft it is acceptable
-
High Fives / Like - 4 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
motownbear
its easier to take an extreme point of view homer/hater...like/dislike then to be open minded and evaluate a situation and it gets more rating that way so just dont get fooled by these things and make up your own mind
He says some good things about football players wanted and needed. We arent running the olympics this is a fricken football team. Olsen was a good example of being drafted based on a 40 time and not what he did in college and it didnt help us out. Flame away at me with this point but its the damn truth
in the B&B interview the best shit I have heard in a long time is the days of the red shirt player is fucking over. Thank god sanity has returned. Talk about wasted draft pick after wasted draft pick. Emery didnt say he wont be taking any risks he just inteligently said there is a barometer of what is acceptable and where and when in draft it is acceptable
Agreed. This is why I believe first round picks need to be difference makers who can come in to contribute at a high level immediately. This team doesn't have enough current talent to stockpile players and wait out their development. Drafting guys who can play now makes a lot of sense to me. We were able to do a better job of that last year and hopefully it will as good or better this year. This is the main reason I don't favor drafting a WR in the first round.
And football players rather than 40 yard dash men. What a novel idea huh mo? That's the way we did it in the 80's and we dominated and won a Super Bowl. We haven't done that since so it's about time we return to what works.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-

Originally Posted by
soulman
I'm really having a hard time understanding where some writers get off criticizing Emery for not outlining his plans for the team and how he's going to go about it. To me this article makes it pretty clear so is Michael Wright one of those who listened to what Emery had to say, understood him, and wrote his interpretation of it? Seems so to me.
There are others who appear to have a predetermined dislike for Emery and criticize both what he says and what he doesn't say as if his job is to please them instead of the people who hired him. Maybe everyone needs top step back, take a deep breath and see what the guy can do instead of finding fault with every word that comes out of the man's mouth.
From reading the above I've got a real good idea of where he stands on player personnel. He wants football players more than he wants athletes and that alone will be a major change in how we draft. He plans to involve Lovie in the player selection process but in the final analysis he has the ultimate control of the roster. With the exception of his agreement to retain Lovie for the 2012 season he has complete control of the decisions normally made by NFL GM's. He may not go into minute detail about everything but he doen't owe anyone that and certainly not some sportswriter who thinks he does. Why tip your hand?
One thing I did find interesting was the comment that JA often strayed from his scouts recommendations. Gee, what a surprise. I think we learned about his tendency to do that when he flip flopped and drafting James Starks. No wonder he fired Gabriel and DePaul. Well maybe we can put to rest the idea that Emery must clean house and get rid of all the scouts because they did a lousy job and that's why we drafted so poorly.
Because they are journalists. And as such, they get paid better when their site/blog/articles generate traffic. And the easiest way to do that? Cause controversy. In this case...right a completely scathing op-piece on our shiny brand spanking new GM. We all know its ridiculous, but by taking a harsher stance, they are merely generating more traffic to their articles, and hence, more money.
Anyone with half a brain knows we wont be able to judge Emery until the draft is over at least. And even then..it will still take years to see if his decisions pan out or not.
-
High Fives / Like - 2 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-
to go even further on what jimmor said do you guys notice the guys that are shut out of halas hall are usually way extremely negative and the guys with access are extreme pro whatever it is bears do? I guess when lively hood is at stake damn the journalism and actual productive work to an article
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-
I know you guys are right about that. In Morrissey's case he's nothing but Jay Moronotti's successor. I've never seen him write anything positive. Rosenbloom writes some pretty sarcastic stuff but he's often dead on with what he criticizes but this was a swift kick in the nuts. I've enjoyed some of his stuff but I lost a lot of respect for over this.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
Phil Emery brings something else to the table when we talk about his entrance onto the the Bears scene as GM, and that's class. Jerry Angelo was condescending often times with his remarks to the media, and his actions he took in building the team were equally as condescending, to the point where those actions actually insulted everyone's intelligence. Angelo never seemed to have a play for anything whenever it came time to upgrade the team via free agency or the draft. Instead, he would half-ass do his job and then blame Lovie Smith for failing to get the team to the playoffs.
Thank God for Phil Emery delivering us a breathe of fresh air. I think we got ourselves the right man for the job.