-

Originally Posted by
soulman
$96 mil over 6 years, $16 mil per on average. My guess is that we were close but that doesn't count here.
I think what annoys me the most is Aaron Rodger comments. He knows he dodged a bullet here. Now let's go get a guy in the draft that's just as likely to make life miserable for him.
Except the odds of that, 1st year especially, are very slim. That's what all the people here who were completely dismissive of signing Mario now have to face. Obviously Emery saw what you, I, and some others saw--that MW was far and above the best FA for us (especially since we got a #1 WR in trade) and there's no first round 19 pick that is anywhere close.
Rodgers knows that too.
Last edited by MPBears68; 03-15-2012 at 04:21 PM.
-
-

Originally Posted by
MPBears68
Except the odds of that, 1st year especially, are very slim. That's why all the people here who were completely dismissive of signing Mario now have to face. Obviously Emery saw what you, I, and some others saw--that MW was far and above the best FA for us (especially since we got a #1 WR in trade) and there's no first round 19 pick that is anywhere close.
Rodgers knows that too.
Exactly why I was so gun-ho about signing him, he would have such a huge impact. But the past is the past, if we signed someone like Wimbley and got a defensive end in the upper rounds we could still have a good pass rush. Wimbley would be the start but with rotating the new guy could have some impact on pass rushing downs. Remember Anderson, as a pass rushing guy, racked up 12 sacks for us his rookie year. I'm not saying we're guaranteed to have that, but it is possible to get an impressive pass rush if we do it right. Whoever is on the other side of Peppers is going to get way less attention due to how good Peppers is, I just hope we can find a way to make this a good pass rushing team.
-

Originally Posted by
Riczaj01
The prices for FA's are absurd; anyone complaining about Forte wanting his, just ask this question, who's a better/more important peice on their team...Forte and his probably 15-20 mil guarantee demands(along the lines of other RB's) or Pierre Garcon who got 40mil and that much in guarantees...also remember that WR's aren't imporant to win SB's, it's the qb the OL and the DL that win you SB's. WR is about the last piece you need.
Garcon only has $20 mil guaranteed of a $42.5 mil deal and $11 mil of that is his SB. The rest is a 100% salary guarantee against injury years 1 and 2 and a very small guarantee in year 3. The rest of any bonus is all incentive based.
This is how things are misunderstood as to structure. Outside of his salary all that he's getting for sure is and $11 mil SB, not $20 mil. They're guaranteeing 100% of his salary, $7.7 mil for the first two years. Big deal. How likely is it that they'd cut him anyway and take a $6.6 mil "dead money" cap hit. So that guarantee includes his salary which would in all likelihood be paid anyway. It's not extra bonus money and if his skills fail after year one they're off the hook. They can cut him without paying him one red cent more.
The only thing he's fully assured of is his SB and first years salary, a total of $13.2 mil. If you look at the actual terms of some of these deals you see a lot of smoke that won't necessarily turn into a fire. Just sayin'.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
Riczaj01
ya b/c you cannot possibly get 10 mil in endorsements in Buffalo, which is just outside NY.
You're joking right? Are you saying he can get $10 mil in endorsements because Buffalo is just outside of NY City????? That's like saying Green Bay is just outside Chicago only Buffalo is twice as far from the City as Chicago is from GB. Maybe I just misunderstood but upstate NY is a whole different world.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
soulman
You're joking right? Are you saying he can get $10 mil in endorsements because Buffalo is just outside of NY City????? That's like saying Green Bay is just outside Chicago only Buffalo is twice as far from the City as Chicago is from GB. Maybe I just misunderstood but upstate NY is a whole different world.
Pretty much. A better comparison would be saying "Springfield is just outside chicago!!"
And on the MWill thing...its not so much what the Bears FAILED to do, its what the Bills DID do...they threw everything they had at him, and they sealed the deal before any other team could get a shot at doing the same. Nothing to blame the Bears on, they did nothing wrong, just congratulate the Bills on their FA tactics, they managed to convince the top Defensive FA to come to a mediocre team in a small market for a deal he probably couldve gotten somewhere else as well. THAT is called salesmanship.
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
soulman
You're joking right? Are you saying he can get $10 mil in endorsements because Buffalo is just outside of NY City????? That's like saying Green Bay is just outside Chicago only Buffalo is twice as far from the City as Chicago is from GB. Maybe I just misunderstood but upstate NY is a whole different world.
All I'm saying is that being in the middle of no where doesn't preclude you from big time endorsements anymore. Farve, Manning both have big time endorsements; ya they are top notch qb's, but if he wants endorsements as a top notch DE(see reggie white in GB for instance) he can get them.
I mistated on the guaranteed, I was talking guaranteed money along the lines of what (i'm assuming) forte wants, 15-20 mil. That is guaranteed, the forty million I know could have a good portion thrown away outside that 20 million.
Last edited by Riczaj01; 03-15-2012 at 05:06 PM.
-
Williams is not worth $50 million guaranteed. Even at age 32, Peppers is still a better overall DE. I'm glad the Bears didn't waste that kind of coin on him.
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
BigBadPapaBear
Williams is not worth $50 million guaranteed. Even at age 32, Peppers is still a better overall DE. I'm glad the Bears didn't waste that kind of coin on him.
In and of itself, no, he probably isnt worth that much, but pretty close.
But...put them two on opposite ends of the same DL? Then yeah...they would both be worth every penny and then some, cant double team em both all the time.
-

Originally Posted by
Jimmors
In and of itself, no, he probably isnt worth that much, but pretty close.
But...put them two on opposite ends of the same DL? Then yeah...they would both be worth every penny and then some, cant double team em both all the time.
If there wasn't a salary cap sure it would be great to have him opposite Peppers. But you can't make those kind of deals these days when you have other stars and up an coming players like the Bears do.
-
Wow, lots to respond to here. Even Springfield is closer to the city than Buffalo is, LOL. But I understand what Ric was trying to say.
Yes Jimmors, I'm disappointed we didn't get him because the fit was perfect but the Bills had the coin to turn it their way and I'll applaud them for that. At about $90 mil I stopped working out numbers in my head. We did what we could but Buffalo did better. Whether or not MWill is better off remains to be seen. And like I said, you can't lose what was never your to begin with.
Ric, Green Bay has a long and very high profile image as Titletown USA. It may be small but GB gets significant national attention and has for as long as I've been aware of pro football. GB has a tremendous global fans base. I doubt Buffalo could match that. I believe they're the second smallest market in the NFL and known primarily as a team that lost 4 consecutive Super Bowls. Green Bay has won more championships than any other NFL team They even attract significant attention in Chicago whereas New Yorkers could care less about a city 400 miles upstate and even less about there football team. Buffalo is trying to court fans from Toronto because they can't fill it with their own. GB does not have that problem. In other words there is no fair comparison between the two. His exposure would be far better in GB than Buffalo but apparently that wasn't enough of a concern to change his mind.
BBPapaBear I think you're right. Pep is a more complete player than MWill is right now. I believe MWill would have benefited greatly from playing with Pep but maybe wearing #90 in Buffalo than #95 or whatever in Chicago was important too. Maybe he just didn't want to share the limelight or then again maybe it was just the almighty buck. It's never a good idea to buy what you can't afford and clearly signing him at his price would have stretched us to thin. I said from the get go that we take our best shot and let the chips fall where they may. We did and we move on. There are other fair damsels to court. Just because the first girl you ask to the prom turns you down is no reason no to ask another.
It's just another day in the life. We didn't have him before and we'll get along without him now. It was just a very delicious dream to conjure up watching Rodgers trying scramble away from that two headed monster. So we draft a good pass rusher instead and save about $90 mil we can put to use elsewhere.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.