-
Bears Should Stop Urlacher From Playing Sunday........Sure, LOL.
Bears need to stop Brian Urlacher from playing on Sunday
BY RICK MORRISSEY rmorrissey@suntimes.com September 5, 2012 10:04PM
ATLANTA - OCTOBER 12: Head coach Lovie Smith (L) and Brian Urlacher #54 of the Chicago Bears watch the replay during an official review in the game against the Atlanta Falcons at the Georgia Dome on October 12, 2008 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
Updated: September 6, 2012 1:57PM
In the hopes that the people with a vote on Brian Urlacher’s playing status will come to their senses, I’m resurrecting a Dan Hampton quote from last week.
“Whoever wants to play him against Indianapolis is nutty,’’ the Bears Hall of Famer said.
A good number of nutty folks apparently are working for the local football team. You would have had an easier time finding Nemo at Halas Hall on Wednesday than finding anyone who wants Urlacher to sit Sunday against the Colts.
Are the Bears better off if their star linebacker plays in the opener or rests his rebellious left knee?
“The [bigger] benefit to the team — that’s our ability to win games and put our defense in the best position — is Brian Urlacher plays,’’ quarterback Jay Cutler said. “That’s the best situation for us.’’
Urlacher practiced with no restrictions Wednesday, which means he’s likely going to play Sunday, which means insanity has established a beachhead. There needs to be one person who, in the face of Urlacher’s deep desire to play, tells him to rest.
That person should be coach Lovie Smith, but he is so smitten with Urlacher and so grateful for all that his middle linebacker has done that I’m not sure the word “no’’ could break the plane of his lips.
If Smith won’t do it, then general manager Phil Emery should. And if Emery won’t, will someone please get in touch with George Halas via the Verizon séance hotline?
It’s hard to understand what the upside is here. The risk is that Urlacher reinjures a knee that has been giving him trouble for months. The reward is they beat a team that went 2-14 last year. Big deal.
When Smith looks at his calendar, he might notice the fat red circle around Sept. 13. That’s the day his team plays the division-rival Packers in Green Bay. It’s also four days after the Colts game. In partnering with Urlacher on the importance of his playing Sunday, the Bears are telling us that all NFL games are created equal. It’s insulting. Anyone in his right mind would want a rested Urlacher for the Packers.
Most football players are willing to play through pain. Most don’t want to let down their teammates. Cowboys tight end Jason Witten reportedly offered to sign a waiver releasing the team from any liability if he reinjured his spleen Wednesday night against the Giants.
That’s why there needs to be the NFL equivalent of a parent making a decision for the child, no matter how much the child stomps his feet.
Urlacher has had two procedures done on the knee, which he hurt in the Bears’ final game last season. No matter how much he wants to be on the field for the opener, someone needs to stop him.
Smith said he could envision a scenario in which he tells Urlacher to take Sunday off.
“Guys, of course, are always going to say that they’re ready to go, but we’ll always watch them and make that final decision,’’ he said. “You want a player to always want to go, but we’ll help him out if it comes to that. But I don’t think it will.’’
The Colts are preparing as if Urlacher will play, which is what the opposing team is supposed to do in this situation. Prepare for the best to show up; count your blessings if he doesn’t.
“I fully expect him to be there,’’ Colts coach Chuck Pagano said. “If he’s not, I’ve watched enough tape to know there’s plenty of talent in the linebacker corps over there. We expect him to play, and we expect him to be out there, and that’s how we’re planning and moving forward.’’
Hampton’s quote about Urlacher and the Colts game was unsolicited. I was talking with him about the Bears’ aging defense. Next thing you know, he’s talking about nuttiness and how it relates to the people who think Urlacher should play Sunday. The topic of the linebacker’s knee is on the mind of anyone who is paying attention to this team. If it was on Urlacher’s mind, he was keeping it to himself. He walked past media members without talking.
Someone needs to save the guy from himself. It’s that or hope the Bears know what they’re doing. Remember what Smith asked fans to do several years ago? “Trust me,’’ he said.
I’d trust him a lot more if he said, “Take a knee this week, Brian.’’
Last edited by soulman; 09-06-2012 at 03:00 PM.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-
-
I love Dan Hampton to death and I'm glad he's always willing to chime in with an opinion or two about the team when asked but in this case I not only have to disagree but wonder how in the hell he could even suggest Urlacher sit out. "Like you did so often during your career Dan". You of all people should know better and the "warrior mentality" involved.
There is no reason for Urlacher to sit as long as Urlacher feels he can play on it and play well enough to deserve staying on the field. There may come a time during the game when this won't be the case but sitting him from the start? No, that I can't see.
What's this rest him for the Indy game to be ready to play for the Packer game BS? Every game is important and provided he's healthy he could probably use the Indy game as his tune up since he's missed all of the preseason and admits he's still not 100% up to speed.
But he might re-injure his knee say the whiners. And if he does then he does and we'll know that the knee is no longer sound and that may lead to the end for Brian Urlacher. Sooner of later the team needs to know if this is just a temporary set back for him that he can play through, a degenerative condition that will shorten his playing days significantly, or an unrepairable problem that he risks re-injuring every time he goes out there.
If I'm the team I want to know now. Hell, as fan I want to know now too. Learning about it after we've made the playoffs and are about to make a SB run isn't the time to find out. If it's gonna happen then I want it to happen before then so that we have someone prepared to take over when it's even more important than it is today. Babying Urlacher now isn't the right way to go about it. Either the knee works or it doesn't and NOW is when we need to know that. Not in December.
Last edited by soulman; 09-06-2012 at 03:18 PM.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.
-

Originally Posted by
soulman
I love Dan Hampton to death and I'm glad he's always willing to chime in with an opinion or two about the team when asked but in this case I not only have to disagree but wonder how in the hell he could even suggest Urlacher sit out. "Like you did so often during your career Dan". You of all people should know better and the "warrior mentality" involved.
Perhaps that is why he is suggesting that Urlacher sits out. He speaks from experience, playing on wounded knees. It is the old "Do as I say, not as I do" attitude. He is the one guy I might actually listen to above all others.
-
For the record though, I hope Urlacher plays. He needs to get back into football shape.
-
I'm fine with him playing. I just hope they don't overwork the knee so it balloons up again like in TC. Be smart about this, especially in the first game or two. It does us NO good to win against the Colts with Urlacher if he ultimately ends up not being on the field when we REALLY need him over the course of a 16 game season AND a playoff run.
Just be smart about it, and don't blow it.
Brian Urlacher
Thanks For The Memories
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
The Benjamin
For the record though, I hope Urlacher plays. He needs to get back into football shape.
Yep, exactly. Pull him if we get up by a couple of touchdowns.

Winston Churchill:
"Since light travels faster than sound, some people appear bright until you hear them speak."
"If you're not a liberal at twenty you have no heart, if you're not a conservative at forty you have no brain."
-
High Fives / Like - 1 BEAR DOWN!, 0 Dislikes
-

Originally Posted by
BearStuff
Yep, exactly. Pull him if we get up by a couple of touchdowns.
This.
Don't overwork the knee in a meaningless situation. Let him play, but don't be stupid. Just like we give him and the old guys rest from practices at times. Be smart. It's a long season. The knee has to last that long season.
Brian Urlacher
Thanks For The Memories
-
I'm just gonna stick with my "we need to know now" scenario. If the knee is gonna continue to give him trouble all season long and he's gonna require time to rest it either during or between games that's something we need to know now and adapt to.
If it is the case then Coztanzo or Roach needs to be talking first team reps every week in practice learning to play and call the defense from the MLB spot. What none of us want to see is a Bears team sailing along on a winning streak like last season and then lose him for good in the 10th game as we did with Cutler and then see the defense struggle for 3-4 weeks trying to pick up the pieces.
Based on what I've read, seen, and garnered from Urlacher's own comments this isn't about the risk of re-injury. The knee has been damaged many times before but this time more severely and it's wearing out like a set of tire on a car only you can replace those tire.
Is the risk of a blow out higher on those bad tires? Yeah but since the tires we're talking about can't be replaced then Brian Urlacher himself will have to decide how best to drive on them. Lovie and Emery can't do that for him.
I'm getting to that age where a lifetime warranty just doesn't mean as much to me anymore as an afternoon nap.
Honey Badger Don't Care. Honey Badger Don't Give a Shit.