Thread: A Little Help For Me/Benji, Please..........

Is this strictly for qb's?

Originally Posted by soulman

Benji has taken the position that you are a bust if you aren't playing the position you were drafted to play. I countered by pointing that many succesful NFL players (WR's primarily) were college QB's when drafted. I'm not trying to embarass him but just want to point out how wrong his logic is on viewpoint.

Here is a partial list: http://profootball.scout.com/2/582822.html

If any of you can think of others who were college QB's when drafted but played as WR's, TE's, or RB's in the pros please add to this list. Hell it's off season so this should be fun. Thanks.

Here's a couple that immediately came to mind;

Marlin Briscoe - college QB/pro WR
Tony Dungy - college QB/pro DB

I will simply re-post what I said in the other thread. Please get your facts straight before telling people what I am saying.

Originally Posted by soulman

I don't have the time to research a complete list of all those of the modern era but here's a start for you. These are all guys who are currently active, some very established like Hines Ward and Antwaan Randle-El, and a few not so well established or they might be rookies and/or 2nd year men.

http://profootball.scout.com/2/582822.html

The point is that they've successfully made the transition from college QB to WR, TE, or RB spots in the NFL. By your twisted logic any of these guys would be considered a bust because they aren't playing QB in the pros. Tell me that you'd call a guy like Hines Ward a bust!

Here are three more from before your time (those count too) who immediately come to mind. None of these guys were busts either.

Marlin Briscoe - QB to WR
Tony Duingy - QB to DB
Max McGee - RB to WR

Benji, since I don't have the time to complete this list I'm gonna post a thread asking our compatriots to add to as they remember guys who've been college QB's that have been successful at other positions in the NFL. I'm gonna do it just because of this sarcastic response.

No, you are misreading and misunderstanding what I said. Allow me to show you what I said again.

Originally Posted by The Benjamin

Not talking about them being a bust because of where they were drafted, but for what they were drafted to do.

For example, Hester was a bust at CB, but has more than excels at returns

I am NOT saying these players are busts. I said they were busts at the positions they were drafted at, and the teams made better use of them in other areas! Hester as a CB was God-awful. A bust of a defensive player, which he was drafted at and even played at for a game or so. After realizing this they moved him elsewhere where his talents could shine. A place he was not drafted at.

Again, a bust as far as what he was drafted to do, but NOT a bust as a player in the NFL.

Understand what I am saying yet?

"However, you can call someone a bust if they are a first round pick, and they are not playing like a first round pick should."

"Should" is a matter of opinion and it's relative to what as expected in the first place. Some players at some postions take longer to develop than others ie; WR's, LT's, OC's to name some examples. So at exactly what point should they be playing like a first rounder and what exactly does that mean? Just because you call them a bust doesn't mean that they are.

" Not talking about them being a bust because of where they were drafted, but for what they were drafted to do."

This is the one that led to my using an example of how many college QB's became very productive players at WR in the NFL
despite being drafted as QB's out of college. Neither one of us knows what they were drafted to do because some, like your
example of Hester, had the ability to play any one of several postions.


"I don't know, you tell me. How many college QBs were drafted as QBs and turned into NFL WRs?"

This was your sarcastic smartass answer and this was my response. http://profootball.scout.com/2/582822.html

There have been quite a few of them as you can see.

Do I understand what you're saying now that you've had the time to examine just what you posted and bend your interpretation of it a little? Yes I do, but my earlier posts to you and this thread are based on what you posted then, that which is bold faced and in quotes, not your current interpretation of what you meant.

If you want to know the truth it was your last post which basically said "show me", as if you somehow thought that I couldn't, that led me to start this thread. I even told you that I would, not to embarass you, but to prove that I knew what I was talking about. I don't say things like that when I can't prove it.

I thought it might be some fun as an excercise in players history for all of us. Do some research on your own and see what you come up with.

Oh, and here's another one; Eldridge Dickey - college QB/NFL WR.

Benj, if you think Hester wasn't drafted as a returner as his main job, I'll disagree.... Strongly

Your forcefulness has me all worked up, Butka!

Originally Posted by Butka

Benj, if you think Hester wasn't drafted as a returner as his main job, I'll disagree.... Strongly

He was just an example.

Anquan Boldin played qb sometimes in college as did hines ward

and if doing for all positions, alot of DT became O-lineman