I agree that some of this is unfair. I haven't seen the entire list but I assume guys like Matt Ryan are ranked above him. Guys like him (and stafford) have the adverse effect. Overated and beloved by the media. A debate I always have with my buddy who is a diehard Falcons fan. If Matt Ryan and Jay Cutler were swapped from the time Jay got to Chi I don't think Ryan would have made it through the first 3 years. Would have probably been crucified by the fans and media and likely ran out after the playoff drought. But for now I don't think Cuter should be ranked below 12. Like I said I haven't seen the list but IMO off the top of my head I would say that..... Rodgers Manning Brady Breese Newton Kaep Other Manning Wilson Luck Big Ben Flacco .......are better, but unless I forgot a few I'm not sure that you can make much argument that ANYONE else is above Cutler. IMO Big Ben and Flacco are serious stretches but without them hes a top 10 qb.