Please Register or Log in to Remove this Advertisement! I think his evaluation should be independent of whether we win or lose. I honestly think that Josh could come out and have a good game and we could very well lose to the Packers. If he has a good game I would give Trestman a lot of credit, because we have seen Josh play poorly, and he is not a starting caliber talent. Cutlers biggest down fall is that he has a rocket arm. Therefore, he has never learned to trust his anticipation of the WR coming open. Josh does not have that strong arm, so he must throw before the WR OR the defender knows it is coming. Payton Manning does not have the strong arm that he once had, but he has learned to throw the ball with anticipation and accuracy.