Matt Forte as a RB and his Value to the Bears...........

Discussion in 'Front Page News' started by soulman, Jun 29, 2014.

  1. 4dabers

    4dabers Pro-Bowler
    DBS Writer

    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2013
    Messages:
    1,200
    Likes Received:
    978
    ßearz ßuckz:
    612ß
    Please Register or Log in to Remove this Advertisement!
    Excellent write-up Soul. Personally, I can't find much to disagree with you about. SO much for spawning debate.
     
    • Funny Funny x 1
  2. weneedmorelinemen

    Joined:
    Jul 30, 2013
    Messages:
    959
    Likes Received:
    545
    ßearz ßuckz:
    489ß
    Ric, all I did was offer a one sentence response to your idea that Benson was the fifth best RB since the 80's in Bears history because, c'mon man, that's stupid. The Bears have had some bad running backs since that time, but Benson is just another bad one on the list. What a player does in a Bears uniform is all that matters to me. What Benson did as a Bengal does not mean anything except to a Benson or Bengal fan.

    Here's the top twenty five Bears rushing leaders. TJ is #6. Anthony Thomas is #7. Cedric Benson does not deserve to smell their shit based on his meager production and ineffectiveness as a Bears starter. The only way he got touchdowns was as a vulture back for TJ.

    Anthony Thomas was a good productive running back for the Bears in the time frame you specified. To say he was not is ignorant. I offered Enis just as an example of poor performance due to serious injury and a little to rile you up.

    [xtable=skin1]
    {tbody}
    {tr}
    {td}Player{/td}
    {td}Seasons{/td}
    {td}# Yrs{/td}
    {td}Att{/td}
    {td}Yds{/td}
    {td}Avg{/td}
    {td}Lg{/td}
    {td}TD{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Walter Payton{/td}
    {td}1975-1987{/td}
    {td}13{/td}
    {td}3,838{/td}
    {td}16,726{/td}
    {td}4.36{/td}
    {td}76{/td}
    {td}110{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Matt Forte{/td}
    {td}2008-2013{/td}
    {td}6{/td}
    {td}1,551{/td}
    {td}6,666{/td}
    {td}4.30{/td}
    {td}68t{/td}
    {td}35{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Neal Anderson{/td}
    {td}1986-1993{/td}
    {td}8{/td}
    {td}1,515{/td}
    {td}6,166{/td}
    {td}4.07{/td}
    {td}80t{/td}
    {td}51{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Rick Casares{/td}
    {td}1955-1964{/td}
    {td}10{/td}
    {td}1,386{/td}
    {td}5,657{/td}
    {td}4.08{/td}
    {td}81{/td}
    {td}49{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Gale Sayers{/td}
    {td}1965-1971{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}991{/td}
    {td}4,956{/td}
    {td}5.00{/td}
    {td}70{/td}
    {td}39{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Thomas Jones{/td}
    {td}2004-2006{/td}
    {td}3{/td}
    {td}850{/td}
    {td}3,493{/td}
    {td}4.11{/td}
    {td}54{/td}
    {td}22{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Anthony Thomas{/td}
    {td}2001-2004{/td}
    {td}4{/td}
    {td}858{/td}
    {td}3,332{/td}
    {td}3.88{/td}
    {td}67t{/td}
    {td}21{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Roland Harper{/td}
    {td}1975-1978,1980-1982{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}757{/td}
    {td}3,044{/td}
    {td}4.02{/td}
    {td}32{/td}
    {td}15{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Willie Galimore{/td}
    {td}1957-1963{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}670{/td}
    {td}2,985{/td}
    {td}4.46{/td}
    {td}77t{/td}
    {td}26{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Matt Suhey{/td}
    {td}1980-1989{/td}
    {td}10{/td}
    {td}828{/td}
    {td}2,946{/td}
    {td}3.56{/td}
    {td}39{/td}
    {td}20{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Ronnie Bull{/td}
    {td}1962-1970{/td}
    {td}9{/td}
    {td}787{/td}
    {td}2,871{/td}
    {td}3.65{/td}
    {td}50{/td}
    {td}9{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Bronko Nagurski{/td}
    {td}1930-1937,1943{/td}
    {td}9{/td}
    {td}633{/td}
    {td}2,778{/td}
    {td}4.39{/td}
    {td}11{/td}
    {td}25{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Bobby Douglass{/td}
    {td}1969-1975{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}373{/td}
    {td}2,470{/td}
    {td}6.62{/td}
    {td}57t{/td}
    {td}20{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Ray Nolting{/td}
    {td}1936-1943{/td}
    {td}8{/td}
    {td}508{/td}
    {td}2,285{/td}
    {td}4.50{/td}
    {td}39{/td}
    {td}10{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Raymont Harris{/td}
    {td}1994,1996-1997{/td}
    {td}3{/td}
    {td}592{/td}
    {td}2,245{/td}
    {td}3.79{/td}
    {td}68t{/td}
    {td}15{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}George Gulyanics{/td}
    {td}1947-1952{/td}
    {td}6{/td}
    {td}509{/td}
    {td}2,081{/td}
    {td}4.09{/td}
    {td}46{/td}
    {td}19{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Brad Muster{/td}
    {td}1988-1992{/td}
    {td}5{/td}
    {td}455{/td}
    {td}2,014{/td}
    {td}4.43{/td}
    {td}35{/td}
    {td}20{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}James Allen{/td}
    {td}1998-2001{/td}
    {td}4{/td}
    {td}515{/td}
    {td}1,978{/td}
    {td}3.84{/td}
    {td}57{/td}
    {td}4{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Gary Famiglietti{/td}
    {td}1938-1945{/td}
    {td}8{/td}
    {td}505{/td}
    {td}1,927{/td}
    {td}3.82{/td}
    {td}31{/td}
    {td}20{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Beattie Feathers{/td}
    {td}1934-1937{/td}
    {td}4{/td}
    {td}338{/td}
    {td}1,846{/td}
    {td}5.46{/td}
    {td}82{/td}
    {td}14{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Bill Osmanski{/td}
    {td}1939-1943,1946-1947{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}368{/td}
    {td}1,753{/td}
    {td}4.76{/td}
    {td}86{/td}
    {td}20{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}George McAfee{/td}
    {td}1940-1941,1945-1950{/td}
    {td}8{/td}
    {td}341{/td}
    {td}1,685{/td}
    {td}4.94{/td}
    {td}70{/td}
    {td}22{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Rashaan Salaam{/td}
    {td}1995-1997{/td}
    {td}3{/td}
    {td}470{/td}
    {td}1,682{/td}
    {td}3.58{/td}
    {td}42{/td}
    {td}13{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Jim Harbaugh{/td}
    {td}1987-1993{/td}
    {td}7{/td}
    {td}296{/td}
    {td}1,609{/td}
    {td}5.44{/td}
    {td}26t{/td}
    {td}15{/td}
    {/tr}
    {tr}
    {td}Cedric Benson{/td}
    {td}2005-2007{/td}
    {td}3{/td}
    {td}420{/td}
    {td}1,593{/td}
    {td}3.79{/td}
    {td}43t{/td}
    {td}10{/td}
    {/tr}
    {/tbody}
    [/xtable]
    http://www.footballdb.com/teams/nfl/chicago-bears/alltime-rushing
     
    • Bear Down! Bear Down! x 1
  3. JustAnotherBearsFan99

    JustAnotherBearsFan99 Assistant Head Coach
    SuperFan DBS Writer

    Joined:
    May 21, 2012
    Messages:
    12,688
    Likes Received:
    4,025
    ßearz ßuckz:
    4,737ß
    I wasn't surprised by the top-5 all time Bears rushers. But it was interesting that TJ was just behind Gale Sayers (Sayers at #5 and TJ at #6). Pretty decent considering TJ was only here for 3 years. I really enjoyed watching him play.

    I still marvel over Payton's career numbers. 110 touchdowns rushing. Another 15 receiving, and 9 passing TD's. 21,803 all purpose yards not including his passing yardage.
     
  4. riczaj01

    riczaj01 DaBears Ditka
    SuperFan DBS Writer

    Joined:
    Nov 4, 2006
    Messages:
    24,421
    Likes Received:
    3,901
    ßearz ßuckz:
    3,688ß
    It's amazing now, but the game has changed so much, the size and speed of the D is just so much more and it just tears apart RB's now. At 5-10 200 I'm not sure he could have played 12 years and kept his production that high; and it's not a knock, I don't think any of the rb's of that era could have. LT played 10 years, but the last 3 just weren't the same, and he might be the last RB to ever have those kind of carries(3.1K to WP's 3.8). That's a high mileage back. AP is only sitting at 2K carries, and Forte only has 1500. Hope that helps keep it in perspective about the idea that Forte has a ton of miles on him.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  5. soulman

    soulman Position Coach
    SuperFan DBS Writer

    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2004
    Messages:
    6,821
    Likes Received:
    2,076
    ßearz ßuckz:
    2,653ß

    Then you don't remember Neal Anderson well at all since he played FB to Walter's HB before Walter retired and he blocked very well both ways.

    He also had over 300 receptions for almost 2800 yds and 20 tds in an era when teams ran the ball far more than they do today and RBs were used less as receivers. He was every bit the all around talent that Forte is today but in a very different era.
     

Share This Page