Please Register or Log in to Remove this Advertisement! I'm not looking at one season of history. I'd say the balance of the evidence is that Jay is Jay and what you see is what you get. He doesn't have additional upside from here. That being said you cannot just dump a player because he isn't a Brady or Manning. There would need to be a Plan B in place and I don't see a viable one where we upgrade Jay. I'll say one thing though.... without playoff wins and some games where Jay provides a glimmer of hope that he can tighten up his turnover margin in tough situations, his bargaining position is greatly weakened. They better not pay him like a Romo.